Yeah I was wondering if maybe the mating surface wasn't flat or something. Looks like one of those things where there was an irregularity between the manifold and block so when the bolt was torqued, it snapped the ear. Wonder if these came from the factory this way and nobody knew it until they took the intake off. With as many miles as 4.0L's get on them before any real work needs to be done, it wouldn't surprise me if it took a long time for people to find this. Let us know if you find anything interesting.
Bookmarks