I have had BFG AT's and didn't care for the off-roadness where I'm at so I went with Dunlop Mud Rovers. Cheap for a mud tire, don't last long on the road(at 50% tread at 19K road) but do extremely well off-road and handle pretty decent on-road.

I can put these on there because she is not my DD but I do like to drive her out on town for the fun of it sometimes