Hanson Bumper Carrier Question

[White98]

Looking for some help with my new Hanson rear bumper.. Installed it no worries, slapped the 31" tire on, and when I stepped back, it looked like the tire carrier part was bending back a good bit. I'm not sure if you can see this in the picture, but it's apparent when in person. How do people get their tires to be more like \ than | in relation to the rear hatch? Seems the bracket doesn't want to mount that way.
Maybe I'm being too much of a fancy boy, but since I shelled out all that dough for the bumper, I'd expect it to fit more flush.

Any help is appreciated, of course.