Need Opinions - Guy asked to buy my Cherokee today

[bsturgis]

I've gotten tons of comments on my Cherokee before, but never this. Today, a guy followed me into a store to ask me if I want to sell my Cherokee. I haven't thought about selling it, but it got me thinking. This guy is serious, and maybe I can get good money for it and buy a new Grand Cherokee. My kids are getting bigger and more room in the back seat would be nice.

Here's what I've got:
-2000 Cherokee Limited - In great condition for it's age - hence the complements - take a look at the picture.
-125,000 miles
-Power Leather Seats
-Overhead console with computer
-Key less entry
-Power windows and locks
-Factory tow package with installed brake controller
-ARB Front Bumper
-Warn 8000 winch
-On board air compressor with tank
-Factory off-road skid plates
-V8 Cherokee front springs & Off-Road Package Rear leafs
-Bilstein Dampers
-ZJ Rear Disk Brakes - with working ABS
-Brand new set of BFG KO2s waiting to go on

Mobil 1 every 4,000 miles. Mobil 1 ATF in the transmission and transfer case. Redline in the diffs. Hell, I even put Bosch Icon wiper blades on it. That's the kinda person I am.

Sooooo, what do you think it's worth? It would be really hard to part ways with it, but everything's always for sale.

Thanks for the input!!!

[abebehrmann]

Where are you located? Clean title? Any rust?

[bsturgis]

Clean title in hand. Zero rust. Greenville, SC.

[abebehrmann]

With the mods/ brand new tires and considering you're in no hurry to sell, I would ask for $2-3k over KBB "very good-excellent" value. Curious as to other opinions though, I am by no means an XJ expert.

[bigjim350]

Here I'd say 4-5k is what they seem to be getting. BUT if your wanting to go off-road with your children I'd keep what you have. Way more capable and cheaper to build than a new grand Cherokee. Now if your just wanting to take them to soccer practice, then yeah sell it and buy a new gc.

[xj-jake]

I've had this happen to me too. But I work at a car dealership too. What I do is put an "I don't wanna sell it" price on it. If the guy is serious he'll pony up and negotiate or pay your price. I did this a few months ago, gave the guy a price and he damn near wrote me a check on the spot. I kinda panicked because I'd have to find another one!